Book Review: A Killer Stitch

Title: A Killer Stitch

Series: Knitting Mysteries, Book #4

Author: Maggie Sefton

My Rating: ★★★☆☆


The House of Lambspun has been bombarded for the holidays. Then an alpaca sheep rancher is found dead in Bellevue Canyon-and knitter and sometime-sleuth Kelly Flynn quickly puts Yuletide frivolities aside. With the deceased’s reputation for loving and leaving the ladies of Fort Connor, many women had a motive to kill him. Kelly also finds herself linked to the prime suspect, a former lover of the wealthy playboy rancher. Charged with keeping both spinner and spurned from going over the edge, Kelly will discover more than a few secrets tangled on this triad’s bobbin. (Via Goodreads)

My Thoughts:

Honestly, this is my least favorite book in the Knitting Mystery Series. First of all, I’m starting to have a hard time with the timeline. This is book 4, yet we haven’t even been with our heroine, Kelly Flynn, for a full year and there have already been 5 murders in and around Fort Connor, six if you count this storyline, that directly touch Kelly’s inner circle. Maybe it is my idealistic idea of town life in Colorado, but I just don’t buy that many murders so close to Kelly Flynn’s social circle in such a short amount of time.

Secondly, by the time we reach the last quarter of the book, Kelly still hadn’t done any detective work. We didn’t learn anything new from the first telling of the murder to nearly the end of the story, except for a bit of gossip here & there. Then the final “piece” that truly points to the killer, just happens to fall into Kelly’s lap? After that her only sleuthing is a second trip back to the bar and having Burt check with the patrol officer. Armed with that she manages to get a confession? No, I’m not buying it.

Although I do love the group of characters in this series, the actual mystery writing for this installment was under par for the standards the author has set previously. In fact, the highlight moment for me was the chaotic introduction of Marty into the group. The entire scene at Curt’s house had me laughing out loud. Since I love the characters so much and enjoy seeing the relationships grow & develop, I will probably continue reading this book series. However, I think I will take a break from binge reading it, to give my brain a palette cleanse. Hopefully, future books in the series return to the sleuthing style I so enjoyed in the first 3 books.

Thanks for taking the time to read my review; if you like you can follow my reading activity on Goodreads.

Featured image created with help from Freepik.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Powered by

Up ↑

The Quilting Nook

Where I share my quilting and crafting journey with a little travel thrown in!

The Twisted Stitcher

Stitching, Books, Faith, & Ramblings

Stitcheroo's life with NF2 & hobbies.

This site is about my life with NF2 and the hobbies that keep me from boredom.xXx

Sew Much 2 Luv

Stitching, Books, Faith, & Ramblings

LucyAnn &Luna craft

crafting,dachshunds including other bits & bobs

It's Daffycat

Stitching, Books, Faith, & Ramblings

Deanna Reads Books

Stitching, Books, Faith, & Ramblings

Blog - S'more House

Stitching, Books, Faith, & Ramblings

The Amateur Librarian

Book Chat, Craft Chat, Chit Chat

Hannah Hand Makes

Cross Stitch | Community | Creativity

Stitching Book Club

Stitching, Books, Faith, & Ramblings

Living Breathing Pages

Drea's Bookshelf

Girl With The Books

Books, thoughts and everything in between.

A Cozy Experience

Stitching, Books, Faith, & Ramblings


irregular updates on family life, books & cross stitch. Lots & lots of cross stitch.

What Saysie Makes

Sewing, Baking and Ramblings


The World of Crafting

%d bloggers like this: